MARCH 2019

4/3/2019

Q1: Do you agree with the verdict of the case? Why or why not?

Q2: Who did you believe more the grandmother or the defendant? Do you believe the defendant took the case seriously?

20 Comments

Bianca Aispuro

4/3/2019 09:21:46 am

1) I do not believe the verdict. I think that their was a possibility that she could have pushed her grandmother , especially considering that she has a violent past and can’t deal with anger in a calm matter. I also believe that a guilty verdict would have benefited her greatly because she would have been able to get anger management classes and family therapy to help her cope with her emotions.

2)It is very hard to say who was telling the truth because both the defendant and the grandmother kept on changing stories. I think that the grandmother was telling the truth but maybe a cloudy one where she may have mixed up a few things. But so did the defendant. Considering the past actions taken by the defendant and her violent actions her plea for innocence is not ligitimat in my eyes. Although she didn’t think she was guilty I felt that she took the case seriously because she answered all the questions properly and made eye contact and was very involved with court in general.

Destiny Rivera

4/3/2019 11:51:08 am

1) I think that she should've been guilty. Given the her past and her anger issues, it wouldn't have been hard to believe that she would've pushed her grandmother, even on accident. She would've also gotten more restorative benefits from being guilty.

2. The grandmother seemed to exaggerate a lot even though she made some valid points. The grandmother also seemed to favor the other granddaughter and didn't seem to understand the other granddaughters perspective. The defendant seemed to take the case seriously and wanted to take the chance to explain herself.

Kristen peralta

4/12/2019 10:06:42 am

Q1: I do not agree with the verdict because there were no consequences for the defendants actions, therefore the defendant hasn’t discovered how her actions affect other people.

Q2: I believe the defendant a little bit more because the grandmother didn’t stick to one thing and she sounded like she was exaggerating the scenario. I don’t think the defendant took the case seriously because she looked annoyed.

Brenda Hernandez

4/12/2019 12:00:11 pm

(1.) Yes I agree with the verdict of the case because the elements that were provided proved she was innocent
(2.)I believe the grandmother more because she had no reason to lie.I don’t believe the defendant took the case seriously

Julianna Vallin

4/12/2019 12:00:32 pm

1,) I agree with the verdict because the grandmother seemed like she was exaggerating things a bit more that she should have but I also believe the defendant should have been guilty because she was also very disrespectful to her grandma and sister and she could at least get some sort of therapy.

2.) I believe the defendant a bit more because in my opinion I feel like the grandmother tried to get the defendant out of the house and also cared more for the little sister more.

Elisa Estrada

4/12/2019 01:58:20 pm

1. I feel like they were right with the questions an they were answer the right way too .
2. I believe the defendant more because I feel like the grandma didn’t want her around An only cares about the defendants sister more

Kayley Brambila

4/12/2019 02:00:24 pm

#1 . Yes I agree with the verdict of the case because it made scene and it was a right choice.

#2 . I believed the defendant more because she sounded like she was telling the truth and she had facts.

Jasmine Garcia

4/21/2019 08:55:51 pm

Q1: I do agree with the verdict because I felt that the defendant was being falsely accused.
Q2: At first I believed the grandmother but then she kept changing her story which made me believe the defendant’s story more.

brenda vega

4/22/2019 01:51:19 pm

yes i did agree with the verdict. the minor does seem in a lot of pain and not a lot of people didn’t talked upon it, which was pretty sad. the minor is young and she’s going through hell. she needs a path to lead her to her bright future.

q2: i believer the minor more because the grandma seemed like she was over reacting like any other grandma.

Sophia Lugo

4/23/2019 02:12:43 pm

I agree with the verdict of the trial because it wasn’t very clear & I didn’t agree with the convictions. I believed the defendant more because the grandmothers story was constantly changing & the defendants stayed the same and seemed reasonable. I do think the defendant took the case seriously because she answered all the questions we asked thoroughly.

Kassandra Pimentel

4/26/2019 01:28:09 pm

1.) I think the verdict was justified since it was more of a family case than a serious one
2.) I believe the defendant but she didn’t seem to take it seriously more like she just said what she did to hurry up and leave

Julie Alvarez

4/26/2019 01:40:03 pm

1.I agree with the verdict of the case because I do not believe she commited the crime ,also this should have never been put to trial,I feel like it was more of a family problem which could have been solved at home
2.I believed the defendant not only because I felt like the grandmother was going against her but because she gave us a brief description of what had happened that day, also the grandma kept switching up her story.

Scott

4/26/2019 01:42:33 pm

I agree with the verdict because I feel like the grandma was lying to try to get the daughter in trouble since the daughter was disrespecting her. I believe the defendant more because if her story stayed the same the whole time but the grandma's story seemed to change.

Alfred Angulo

5/23/2019 08:31:13 am

1. I agreed with the verdict of the case because they said she admitted to everything that she has ever done except push the grandma out of the way.

2.I believed the defendant more than the grandmother but I don't think they took the case serious.

Yonatan Flores

5/23/2019 08:33:41 am

1: i believe with the verdict of the case because she was truthful about everything in the case but did not agree to pushing her grandma out of the way.

2:i believe the defendant more than the grandma because the grandma seemed like she was just trying to get rid of the defendant from her home. i also don't believe that the defendant took the trial serious.

Rodrigo Romero

5/23/2019 08:41:04 am

I agree completly with the outcome of this trial. The grandma had her heart at the right place but evidence was flawed.I doubt the defendant took the case seriously but I had a felling the grandma was over reacting so we found the defendant not guilty

Abraham Benitez

5/28/2019 01:51:39 pm

The defendant was obviously guilty, even as a minor with the whole situation, she did not act in a calm manner which would have prevented the whole arrest.
The grandmother seems like the more reliable source in most aspects, but there were times when she seemed susceptible.

Mario Cervantes

5/28/2019 02:20:04 pm

Q1. I agree with the verdict because the grandmother didn’t really seem to stick with one story, she kept changing it.
Q2. I believed the defendant more because her story made actually sense. I don’t think the defendant took the case serious enough.

Samuel Torres

5/28/2019 02:45:22 pm

1)I agree with the verdict because I think the grandmother may have been lying.2)I believe the defendant more because the grandmother kept on switching story’s

Jason Alcaraz

5/28/2019 02:50:35 pm

I agree with the verdict because the grandma seemed to changes her story while the defendant sticked to one story.

I believe the defendant because she seems calm and knows what she was talking about, the grandma looked like she was struggling

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.

MARCH 2019

Leave a Reply.

Categories